A Culinary Journey Through Paradise

Key West, Florida, is renowned for its laid-back island vibe, stunning sunsets, and, of course, its vibrant food scene. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, a juicy steak, or an inventive twist on classic dishes, Key West offers something for every palate. Here’s a guide to the top 10 restaurants that are sure to make your culinary experience in this tropical paradise unforgettable.

1. Latitudes

Cuisine: Caribbean, Seafood
Vibe: Elegant, Scenic
Must-Try: Lobster Bisque, Sunset Dinner

Latitudes, located on the private island of Sunset Key, offers one of the most romantic dining experiences in Key West. Accessible by a short boat ride, this fine dining establishment is perfect for a sunset dinner. Known for its incredible views of the Gulf of Mexico, Latitudes serves up fresh seafood, succulent steaks, and creative cocktails. The Lobster Bisque is a favorite among regulars, as is the signature Sunset Key Fish.

2. Blue Heaven

Cuisine: Caribbean, American
Vibe: Funky, Outdoor, Casual
Must-Try: Lobster Omelet, Key Lime Pie

A Key West institution, Blue Heaven is located in a colorful and quirky old house with chickens roaming freely around the outdoor dining area. It’s a beloved spot for breakfast, brunch, and lunch. The Lobster Omelet is a standout, and their Key Lime Pie is legendary—some say it’s the best on the island. The laid-back atmosphere, complete with live music and vibrant decor, makes Blue Heaven a must-visit.

3. El Siboney

Cuisine: Cuban
Vibe: Casual, Family-friendly
Must-Try: Ropa Vieja, Tostones

If you’re craving authentic Cuban cuisine, El Siboney is the place to go. This unassuming gem offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere and a menu packed with traditional Cuban favorites. The Ropa Vieja (shredded beef in a tomato-based sauce) and Tostones (fried green plantains) are crowd-pleasers. The restaurant’s affordable prices and hearty portions make it a local favorite.

4. The Saint Hotel Restaurant & Bar

Cuisine: Modern American, Seafood
Vibe: Upscale, Trendy
Must-Try: Grilled Octopus, Wagyu Beef Burger

The Saint Hotel combines high-end sophistication with the laid-back spirit of Key West. Their restaurant features a trendy atmosphere with a menu that’s a blend of contemporary American and seafood dishes. The Grilled Octopus and Wagyu Beef Burger are particularly popular, and the craft cocktails elevate the dining experience. Whether you’re enjoying an intimate dinner or a lively evening out, The Saint is always a top choice.

5. Conch Republic Seafood Company

Cuisine: Seafood
Vibe: Waterfront, Casual
Must-Try: Conch Fritters, Grilled Mahi-Mahi

The Conch Republic Seafood Company offers a quintessential Key West dining experience. Located along the waterfront, this restaurant specializes in local seafood, including Conch Fritters, Grilled Mahi-Mahi, and fresh oysters. With a laid-back atmosphere, outdoor seating, and beautiful views of the harbor, Conch Republic is perfect for a relaxing lunch or dinner by the water.

6. Santiago’s Bodega

Cuisine: Tapas
Vibe: Cozy, Intimate
Must-Try: Patatas Bravas, Bacon-Wrapped Dates

For those who love small plates and sharing, Santiago’s Bodega is the place to go. This cozy tapas bar is known for its bold flavors and wide variety of options. The Patatas Bravas (crispy potatoes with spicy tomato sauce) and Bacon-Wrapped Dates are highly recommended, and the sangria flows freely, making for a perfect night out with friends or a romantic dinner for two.

7. Azur

Cuisine: Mediterranean, Seafood
Vibe: Modern, Chic
Must-Try: Grouper Fillet, Mediterranean Paella

Azur brings a taste of the Mediterranean to Key West, offering an innovative menu with a focus on fresh seafood and Mediterranean-inspired dishes. The Grouper Fillet is a standout, and the Mediterranean Paella is a delicious option for those craving a hearty dish with rich flavors. With a chic atmosphere and exceptional service, Azur is perfect for a special night out.

8. A&B Lobster House

Cuisine: Seafood, Steakhouse
Vibe: Elegant, Historic
Must-Try: Lobster Tail, Filet Mignon

A&B Lobster House is a Key West classic, combining the best of seafood and steak in a historic setting overlooking the water. Known for its exceptional lobster and high-quality steaks, the Lobster Tail and Filet Mignon are particularly popular. The intimate, upscale atmosphere makes it ideal for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal.

9. The Key West Cuban Coffee Shop

Cuisine: Cuban, Breakfast & Brunch
Vibe: Casual, Cozy
Must-Try: Cuban Sandwich, Café Cubano

If you’re looking for a breakfast or lunch spot that serves up a taste of Cuba, The Key West Cuban Coffee Shop is a must-visit. Their Cuban Sandwich is a local favorite, and their Café Cubano (sweetened Cuban coffee) is a perfect pick-me-up. It’s a great spot for a quick, delicious meal or a relaxing morning with a cup of coffee.

10. Hogfish Bar & Grill

Cuisine: Seafood, American
Vibe: Waterfront, Casual
Must-Try: Hogfish Sandwich, Conch Chowder

Located on Stock Island, just a short drive from downtown Key West, Hogfish Bar & Grill is a local favorite. Specializing in the signature Hogfish (a mild, white fish native to the area), the Hogfish Sandwich is a must-try, as is the Conch Chowder. With a relaxed, waterfront setting and a laid-back vibe, Hogfish is the perfect spot for a casual meal with a view.

Honorable Mentions:

  • Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar: A trendy spot with modern American cuisine and seafood, offering a great atmosphere for a casual yet upscale dining experience.
  • Bistro 245: Located inside the luxurious Ocean Key Resort, this restaurant serves contemporary American cuisine with beautiful views of the Gulf.

Key West’s dining scene is as diverse and flavorful as the island itself. From elegant seafood dining on a private island to casual bites in vibrant outdoor settings, these top 10 restaurants will ensure that your time in Key West is full of delicious memories.